Sex-specific innate immunity and ageing in long-lived fresh water turtles (Kinosternon flavescens: Kinosternidae)
Immunity & Ageing volume 20, Article number: 11 (2023)
The progressive deregulation of the immune system with age, termed immunosenescence, has been well studied in mammalian systems, but studies of immune function in long-lived, wild, non-mammalian populations are scarce. In this study we leverage a 38-year mark-recapture study to quantify the relationships among age, sex, survival, reproductive output and the innate immune system in a long-lived reptile, yellow mud turtles (Kinosternon flavescens; Testudines; Kinosternidae).
We estimated rates of survival and age-specific mortality by sex based on mark-recapture data for 1530 adult females and 860 adult males over 38 years of captures. We analyzed bactericidal competence (BC), and two immune responses to foreign red blood cells - natural antibody-mediated haemagglutination (NAbs), and complement-mediated haemolysis ability (Lys) - in 200 adults (102 females; 98 males) that ranged from 7 to 58 years of age captured in May 2018 during their emergence from brumation, and for which reproductive output and long-term mark-recapture data were available.
We found that females are smaller and live longer than males in this population, but the rate of accelerating mortality across adulthood is the same for both sexes. In contrast, males exhibited higher innate immunity than females for all three immune variables we measured. All immune responses also varied inversely with age, indicating immunosenescence. For females that reproduced in the preceding reproductive season, egg mass (and therefore total clutch mass) increased with age,. In addition to immunosenescence of bactericidal competence, females that produced smaller clutches also had lower bactericidal competence.
Contrary to the general vertebrate pattern of lower immune responses in males than females (possibly reflecting the suppressive effects of androgens), we found higher levels of all three immune variables in males. In addition, contrary to previous work that found no evidence of immunosenescence in painted turtles or red-eared slider turtles, we found a decrease in bactericidal competence, lysis ability, and natural antibodies with age in yellow mud turtles.
Ageing in many vertebrate systems is characterized by organismal senescence – declining efficiency and performance of physiological and cellular processes  leading to declining age-specific survival and fertility with advancing age . Studies of ageing in wild populations of vertebrates have often focused on quantifying age-related changes in fecundity and mortality , but less often on physiological mechanisms that may contribute to such demographic ageing (e.g., [4,5,6]). One such candidate physiological mechanism is immune function, which plays a critical role in survival. Reduced immune function has been shown to negatively impact survival and reproduction [6,7,8]. The progressive deregulation of the immune system with age, termed immunosenescence, has been well studied in humans for both innate immunity (whose dysregulation with age can lead to chronic inflammation ), and acquired immunity, where the best studied changes are an increase in memory T cells and decrease in naïve T cells with advancing age (but here too, immunosenescence remains enigmatic ). However, age-specific changes in the immune system of long-lived, wild, non-mammalian populations are not well described in the literature, and studies focusing on reptile immunosenescence are even more rare (reviewed in ).
Organismal senescence, which gives rise to demographic senescence in populations, evolved in the wild. Thus, studies on natural populations are well positioned to reveal evolutionarily conserved senescent processes that are possible constraints for how ageing occurs. At the same time, studying organismal and demographic senescence in the wild provides realistic ecological contexts and reveals the extent to which ageing mechanisms are flexible. In particular, reptiles have many features that recommend them for studies of the mechanisms of senescence, including immunosenescence. First, they are the sister clade to mammals, which together form the monophyletic clade of amniotes; immune function and cell signaling pathways are highly conserved across amniotes (reviewed in ). Second, reptiles exhibit a number of phenotypes that allow the study of senescence across a range of physiological and morphological contexts, which is not possible in most mammalian species (e.g., hypoxia resistance, freeze-tolerance, venom, armor, heat tolerance, reviewed in ). Excepting birds, reptiles are poikilothermic, and many continue growing as adults (e.g.,  but see ) and increasing their fecundity with advancing age ([14,15,16,17], reviewed in ). Furthermore, many reptile lineages have unique morphological features. Examples of the latter include protective phenotypes - such as external ribcages in turtles and venom in some snakes.
Recent phylogenetic analyses of rates of mortality ageing showed strong support for the hypothesis that reptile lineages with protective phenotypes had longer lives and slower ageing than similarly sized mammals, particularly across turtles , (see also [19, 20]). Indeed, across 300 species of wild-sampled tetrapods , turtles were unique in that the entire lineage was characterized by species with nearly negligible mortality ageing and long lifespans – a finding mirrored in captivity . Given that growth (and therefore, fecundity) may continue over the adult lifespan, selection against deleterious mutations with late-age phenotypes may be stronger in older ages in turtles and other reptiles with these characteristics relative to mammals (as in ). These traits suggest that immunosenescence may not manifest in the same manner in reptiles when compared to other amniote vertebrates, such as mammals or birds, and may even be absent due to selective pressures on maintaining immune function with increased reproduction (e.g., ). Here we focus on expanding the comparative landscape of ageing studies in turtles to promote their use as models of slow ageing.
The immune system of turtles, like other amniotes, includes innate and acquired components (reviewed in ), but recent analyses suggest that reptiles may rely more heavily on innate defenses relative to mammals and birds . Specifically, although reptiles have B and T cells associated with adaptive immunity, the traditional adaptive rapid response upon secondary exposure to pathogens may rely more heavily on innate immunity . There is a growing literature on age-associated patterns of innate immunity in ectothermic reptiles [4, 25,26,27], which affords a first line of defense against foreign pathogens. At the same time, the study of sex-differences in both organismal senescence and demographic ageing has expanded to better phylogenetic coverage, including reptiles . Importantly, these studies are possible in wild populations only with the ability to accurately age individuals, which requires long-term study for long-lived species ([29, 30], reviewed in ). Thus we add to this literature by investigating aspects of sex- and age-specificity of innate immunity, survival, female reproduction, and relationships among them in a long-lived reptile. We leverage a 38-year mark-recapture study of known-age yellow mud turtles (Kinosternon flavescens) to quantify the relationships among age, sex, survival, and reproductive output on the innate immune system as an integrative approach to understanding immunosenescence. Like other turtles, this species was found to have slow ageing when the sexes are considered together . Specifically, we assessed three innate immune measures – circulating natural antibodies, complement-mediated lysis ability, and bactericidal competence of plasma – in our long-term study population in Nebraska (USA). In accordance with the existing paradigm of innate immunosenescence, we predicted that measures of innate immunity would decline with advancing age, despite some evidence to the contrary [5, 32].
Two hundred animals were sampled in 2018 for immune variables (N = 98 males, N = 102 females) and these observations comprise our immune data. Of these 102 females, 85 reproduced in 2017 and these comprise our female reproductive data. Finally, for the analysis of mortality senescence in the population as a whole, we used our long-term database of N = 2380 unique known-age individuals (N = 860 males, N = 1530 females). In our sample of immune data individuals (200 adults), age was highly correlated with body size; older animals were larger in both mass and length (e.g., body mass, r = 0.58, Pr. < 0.0001; plastron length, r = 0.60, Pr. < 0.0001). Therefore body size was not included in models where age was an explanatory factor.
In the immune data individuals, adult females were smaller than males and tended to be older (Table 1, Fig. S2), a result that is mirrored in the population as a whole (see Fig. 5 in ). Because adult females in our immune sample were significantly older than males, we z-transformed age for all analyses of innate immune function to dissociate the confound of age and sex. This allowed for a comparison of relatively old and young adult males and females.
In the population as a whole, females had greater median and maximum adult lifespans (ages at which 50 and 95% of adults had died). Adult male and female turtles both exhibited age-related morality increases, indicating ageing. Initial adult mortality rate was higher in males than females, but rates of mortality acceleration were equivalent (Table 1, Fig. 1).
In our immune subsample of individuals, the three measures of innate immune function were significantly (positively) correlated with each other (natural antibody-mediated haemagglutination, complement-mediated haemolysis, and bactericidal competence, Table S1). But because correlations were weak (all |r| < 0.28), we analyzed each variable separately. For all three variables, batch represents reagents used. For bactericidal competence, five individual lyophilized pellets of Escherichia coli were used to generate control plates across the experiment; as control plates decreased in their colony count, a fresh control solution was made. For natural antibodies and cell lysis capability, two separate bottles of rabbit red blood cells were used sequentially. Significant variation among E. coli pellets and individual rabbits (that generate the red blood cells) is expected, and we controlled for it here as a batch effect in our models. All three immune variables declined with advancing age (BC and Lysis, Pr < 0.05; Nabs, Pr = 0.08, Table 2, Fig. 2) and were higher in males than females (Table 2, Fig. 3).
For the 85 females in our data for which we had both most-recent reproductive output and immune measures, clutch size did not change with age, whereas egg mass increased with age (Tables 3, S2, Fig. 4). Because clutch size did not change with age, a third measure of reproductive effort, total clutch mass followed the identical trend as egg mass and was not considered further. Interestingly, the three females greater than 50 years old had lower age-corrected egg mass (age > 50 years) than females in the next lowest age interval (N = 13 age 40–50 years of age (t = 2.45, Pr. = 0.014)) suggesting the possibility of senescence in reproductive output in very old females (see Fig. 4).
For these 85 reproductive females, older females followed the same trend observed for all adults: reduced bactericidal competence and complement-mediated haemolysis with age (Table 3, see Fig. 1). In addition, females with larger clutches - irrespective of age - had higher bactericidal competence than those with smaller clutches (Fig. S1). In contrast to clutch size, we found no effects of egg mass on immune function (data not shown).
Mortality and reproductive senescence
Female yellow mud turtles live longer than males in this population; however, they age at similar rates (Fig. 1) and age-specific mortality increases with age in both sexes (Fig. 1), albeit slowly. These data demonstrate slow mortality senescence in this species, but we found no evidence of reproductive senescence in our female samples. Small acceleration in adult age-specific mortality in turtles have been reported in the large tetrapod phylogenetic study  as well as in individual long-term studies for giant tortoises , painted turtles ([35, 36] but see [37, 38] and species of hinge-back tortoises ); however, in other turtle species, mortality often remains constant with advancing adult age , or decreases with age [3, 15, 41]. Across captive populations of turtles (e.g., zoo records) da Silva et al.  found that most turtle species exhibited slow or negligible declines in mortality with age. Female reproductive ageing (i.e., declines in age-specific reproductive output) is not seen in turtle species thus far (painted turtles , Blanding’s turtles [15, 41], desert tortoises , and box turtles ). Warner and colleagues  did note decreased painted turtle hatchling survival from the oldest female painted turtles, despite no decrease in reproductive output. In addition, many reproductive studies of turtles have demonstrated positive correlations between clutch size, egg size and/or clutch mass with body size in turtles (; reviewed ), where body size is often positively associated with age in turtles (e.g., the present study, [17, 32], but see ). These data suggest that reproductive senescence rarely occurs in turtles, if at all.
Sex-specific longevity and ageing
Studies of sex differences in organismal and demographic senescence remain rare in non-mammalian species. There are likely two reasons for this: initial reports of demography on wild populations often pool data for sufficient power to estimate mortality acceleration; and in many species the sex of juveniles is unknown due to a lack of external genitalia, and must rely on the development of secondary sexual phenotypes to assign sex in newly mature animals. In a review of captive longevity data, da Silva and colleagues  reported that average adult male life expectancy exceeded that of females by about 20%, contrary to our results for yellow mud turtles. However, greater longevity in females in wild populations of turtles appears to be the pattern (painted turtles [28, 45]), spotted turtles [46, 47], wood turtles , map turtles  cooters , box turtles , and red-eared sliders ). In contrast, we are aware of only two studies that have reported that male turtles outlive females in the wild (gopher tortoises  but see , and a population of painted turtles . Further data are needed, but these field data contrast with the captive records summarized by , and suggest a possible sex by environment interaction related to longevity and ageing.
Sex-specific immune function
We found higher levels of immune function in males than females, the opposite of the general pattern in vertebrates [55, 56], and presumed to be related at least in part to immune system suppression by androgens [57, 58]. Many species of turtles are appropriate models for this question because they lack sex chromosomes, and therefore the sexes have identical genome architecture at conception. They instead have temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) whereby sex is determined by the thermal environment experienced during the critical period of embryonic development, removing any confound between sex-specific genomes and sex-specific sexual development . López-Pérez and colleagues  found no difference in bactericidal competence between males and females in a species of musk turtle (another kinosternid turtle with TSD). Likewise, Zimmerman and colleagues [32, 61, 62] found no sex difference in measures of innate immunity in red-eared slider turtles (also with TSD). In contrast, in painted turtles  – another species with TSD –, higher complement-mediated haemolysis ability was reported in males, and higher natural antibody titres in females, with no sex effect on bactericidal competence. In addition, Freedberg and colleagues  found that cool, male-producing incubation temperatures in another TSD turtle enhanced immunocompetency in males more than females, but found no such effects in a closely related congener. Although these preliminary data seem to suggest that turtles may not follow the general vertebrate pattern of lower immune responses in males, further research is clearly needed. Following ecoimmunology theory that posits associations between immune defenses and life-history strategies [64, 65], we would expect the longer-lived sex to invest more heavily in acquired relative to innate immunity ; limited data on sex-specific longevities precludes a comprehensive test across species.
Behavioral differences and activity patterns may subject female yellow mud turtles to greater infection pressures than males, which may suppress female immune function [55, 56]. Our study species has an unusual annual activity cycle (see Methods). At our study site adult males emerge from brumation an average of 5 days before females in the spring [Iverson and Greene, unpublished data], remain active in the water in June during the extended nesting forays by females, and on average move to summer estivation later than females . Hence, the annual activity period of this species is unusually short, with a typical male being active in the water perhaps 25% longer than a typical female. However, it is not clear why the shorter activity season of females would expose them to greater immune system pressures. As well, reproductive activity differs between males and females, with mating and fertilization occurring in the water column, after which females must emerge from the water to land to deposit their eggs (whereas males have no such mandatory foray onto land) .
Reptilian circulating steroid concentrations are highly seasonal (e.g., [68, 69]), and thus the pattern we observed of higher immune function in males might be attributed to sampling only during spring emergence – i.e., very early in the season. Seasonal variation in turtle androgens have been reasonably well studied, and circulating testosterone levels for male turtles are generally very low in the early spring (review in ), whereas it peaks in the spring for females as they prepare for ovulation [69,70,71,72,73,74]. Testosterone is known to suppress immune function (, but see ) and this might explain the lower immune responses in females compared to males. However, estradiol is known to enhance immune function , and it is generally elevated in females in the early spring, followed by a peak soon afterward in association with ovulation and oviposition (, reviewed in ). Thus, based on our early spring sampling, estradiol and testosterone patterns are unlikely explanations for the lower immune responses observed in our females. Unfortunately, we lack data for circulating hormone levels in our study species, but given the general patterns just described, the impact of circulating steroids on immune function is still not clear.
Female reproduction and immune function
We found no evidence for an immune cost to female reproduction. Neither clutch size (Table 3) nor egg mass (data not shown) negatively impacted any immune variable. Indeed, females that laid larger clutches of eggs had higher bactericidal capability (Fig. S1). Life history theory predicts that individuals must allocate resources into traits such as those that support self-maintenance and reproduction in order to maximize fitness . However, reproduction represents a significant energetic cost to females and thus resources allocated to reproduction may come at the expense of other traits . Females investing heavily in current reproduction may thus be expected to experience trade-offs with current immune effectiveness . This trade-off between reproduction and immune function has been examined in other reptiles with mixed results. Gravid western terrestrial garter snakes (Thamnophis elegans) displayed lower T-lymphocyte proliferative ability in response to a mitogen relative to non-gravid conspecifics but exhibited no difference in BC between reproductive states . In contrast, gravid pygmy rattlesnakes (Sistrurus milarius) displayed decreased BC ability relative to non-gravid snakes . Measures of innate immunity between reproductive states in painted turtles (Chrysemys picta) were age dependent . Specifically, younger females that had large clutches exhibited greater lysis ability than older females with similarly large clutch sizes. However, this same study found increased BC in older females which is in contrast to the findings in this study of decreasing immune function with advancing age. Additionally, irrespective of age, we found that larger clutch sizes were correlated with higher BC and that there was no effect of reproduction on natural antibody production or lysis ability. These results suggest that trade-offs between immune function and reproduction are likely immune-component specific.
Of the innate immune variables we examined in yellow mud turtles, we found evidence of immunosenescence in all three (Fig. 2; Table 2). Results from other studies are mixed. For example, larger (presumably older) red-eared sliders exhibited no change in BC compared to smaller individuals [32, 61], similar to findings for bactericidal competence in painted turtles where age was known . This latter study also reported increases in haemagglutination in older animals. Obviously, no pattern of age-related changes in the innate immune system in turtles is yet evident. Among other non-avian reptiles, the results are also quite variable (reviewed in [8, 26]). For example in populations of garter snakes, both haemagglutination and haemolysis ability decrease in older snakes [27, 80], as does immune response to the mitogen phytohaemagglutinin in Dickerson’s collared lizards . While in water pythons, haemagglutination increases with age . Further research will be necessary to understand this variation in the direction of age-related changes in innate immunity in reptiles generally, and turtles specifically. In contrast, data from mammals and birds broadly show declines in immune function with age. Furthermore, in these taxa most immunosenescence observed occurred in the adaptive immune system [83,84,85] with less pronounced changes found in innate immunity (reviewed in ), although here too, patterns are not necessarily consistent across innate immunity measures . However, in reptiles, the adaptive immune system responds more slowly to challenges and does not exhibit robust responses during repeated pathogen exposure (reviewed in [24, 87]). Thus, innate immune function, and age-related changes in such function may be critical to overall immune health in reptiles.
Here we have attempted to expand the comparative considerations of innate immunosenescence, and its interactions with mortality and reproductive ageing. We chose a long-studied wild population of (yellow mud) turtles to test for associations among these measures of ageing because recent broad comparative studies have identified the turtle clade as having exceptionally slow ageing and long lifespans. Notwithstanding, measures of ageing mechanisms require known ages, which is only achievable through long-term study for wild, long-lived species. We found that mortality and immunity had sex-specific characteristics; females lived longer and had lower innate immune function than males. This result is striking based on the temperature-dependency of sex determination, thus ruling out contributions of sex chromosomes to sex-specific ageing. All three measures of innate immunity declined with advancing age. In females, clutch mass increased with advancing age in females, and reproductive output did not predict innate immune function other than that females with larger clutches had higher bactericidal competence, suggesting no obvious cost of reproductive effort for innate immunity in females. This is the first study to examine three axes of ageing in turtles, a group characterized by slow-to-negligible ageing. These findings on immunosenescence, mortality, and reproduction suggest turtles as a new model for understanding the mechanisms of slow ageing, or, more precisely, the study of universal ageing mechanisms (such as immunosenescence) in a monophyletic group characterized by slow adult mortality acceleration and negligible reproductive senescence.
Tissue sampling for the yellow mud turtles (YMT) for this study took place in May 2018 on Gimlet Lake at our long-term research site on the Crescent Lake National Wildlife Refuge (CLNWR), in Garden County, Nebraska, USA (41°45.24′N, 102°26.12′W). The Gimlet Lake marsh complex is a shallow (average depth 0.8 m), sandhill lake with marsh habitat . YMTs exhibit temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) with females produced under warm incubation conditions and both males and females produced under cooler conditions . Mark-recapture and nesting ecology studies were ongoing here from 1981 through 2018. At this site, YMTs typically overwinter terrestrially buried in upland sandhills adjacent to wetlands, emerge in April and May, and migrate to the water, and then most females return to the same sandhills to nest in June, although some do not reproduce every year [67, 87]. By July all turtles begin leaving the wetlands to estivate in the sandhills for the remainder of the summer (see also ). During field seasons, drift fences were constructed parallel to the shore between three overwintering sites and the lake, and monitored continuously each day.
During years (including 2017) when the fences were in place during the nesting season, each captured female was x-rayed to determine clutch size, and the width of each egg on each x-ray was measured. A regression equation relating mean clutch x-ray width with actual mean egg mass from a subset of nests that were subsequently excavated allowed us to estimate egg mass and clutch mass (both in g) for each gravid female in 2017 (n = 85). The equations for these relationships and fit are as follows: Actual Egg Width = 0.98(Estimated Egg Width) + 1.52, R2 = 0.89; Actual Egg Mass = 0.64(Estimated Egg Mass) – 6.07, R2 = 0.85; and in a sample of N = 1795 YMT eggs collected over several years egg width can be reliably used to estimate egg mass (and therefore total clutch mass) Egg Mass = 0.68(Egg Width) – 6.77, R2 = 0.85 (Iverson, unpublished data). This enabled us to examine the effects of those measures of reproductive output on immunity in the spring of 2018 as these 85 female turtles emerged from brumation.
Once captured, turtles were transported back to the field laboratory where morphometric data were recorded, including maximum carapace length (CL in mm), maximum plastron length (PL in mm), and body mass (BM in g). Up to 0.5 ml of whole blood was collected from the cervical sinus via 26 gauge heparinized syringe, centrifuged (7000 rpm) in a cryotube for 5 min to separate blood components. Blood plasma was pipetted to a separate cryotube. Both plasma and packed red blood cells were immediately flash frozen in liquid nitrogen until transport to Iowa State University for storage at − 80 °C. Sampled turtles (98 males and 102 females) were transported back to their initial capture location and released on the opposite side of the fence to proceed to the lake.
Since this study began in 1981, age in years upon initial capture of each turtle was estimated as the number of winters post-hatching. Age estimation is the same every year and, thus, our methods for age determination apply to all data considered herein (population and immune subsample). Because only a single scute annulus is produced each year in this population, age of immature turtles usually equals the total number of annuli present. However, during extremely harsh years, there may not be any growth, and two annuli may appear as one. Hence, counts of annuli are minimum ages, and might be underestimated if annuli are not counted and evaluated in the context of general shell growth patterns in the whole population. By comparing the pattern of the increments in scute growth of an unaged juvenile turtle with the general pattern of scute growth in the population, age-at-first-capture could be reliably determined up to at least 12 years. We counted the minimum number of annuli on adult turtles captured in the early years of the study, and age was estimated for all of those turtles if the number of annuli was less than 20. However, most turtles were initially marked individually and aged before their sixth winter, and aged subsequently based on the actual recapture interval. Adult females were significantly older (and smaller) than males in our samples (Table S3; unpaired t-test, P = 0.0003, See Fig. S2 and Fig. 5 in ). Therefore age was z-transformed within each sex to a mean of 0 with unit variance. This variable “zAge” was used in all statistical analyses. We excluded data from 26 unsexed juveniles.
Reproductive output – clutch size, total clutch mass – increased with increasing size and age. Therefore, for the analyses that included female reproductive output along with age in the model, we used raw values of reproductive output without correcting for body size. All linear models were performed in SAS v. 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA).
Survivorship and age-specific mortality rates of adult Kinosternon flavescens from western Nebraska were estimated based on the Gompertz model (Table 1) [18, 90, 91] which estimates an initial mortality probability at starting age, and the rate of accelerating mortality across the lifespan. More complicated models (e.g., including a constant Makeham term for age-independent mortality, including a deceleration parameter) were not supported by these data based on the change in AIC (computed in the BaSTA R package ). Gompertz modeling was applied to our long-term mark-recapture data set from Gimlet Lake, including data from 1530 individual females and 860 individual males. Age at maturity averaged 11 years for both sexes, which is known from the long-term monitoring of age and reproduction in this population [88, 92, 93]. Because maturation is size-dependent, these estimates of maturation age (i.e., 11 yr.) are maximum estimates (for example, an occasional male turtle can be identified at younger ages). We tested the sensitivity of using an average maturation age of 10 years with no appreciable effect on estimates of lifespan and mortality ageing (data not shown). Maximum and median adult lifespan were calculated as the number of years after the age of first reproduction until 95 and 50% of the adults in the synthetic cohort were estimated to have died. Datasets were analyzed using the ‘basta’ function from the BaSTA package for R .
Natural antibody-mediated haemagglutination and complement-mediated haemolysis (NAbs, Lysis) ability are reported to be the first line of defense against pathogens in vertebrates (reviewed in ), and these measures of innate immune function have been studied in many reptile species (e.g., [4, 5, 32, 80, 82, 95]). We completed the assays for NAbs and lysis ability according to the haemolysis–haemagglutination assay adapted from  for use in painted turtles [5, 97]) using rabbit red blood cells. We used two bottles of rabbit red blood cells (HemoStat HemoStat Laboratories, Dixon, CA, USA) to complete all assays. We ran all plates with positive and negative controls and samples in duplicate. Higher titres for haemagglutination indicate greater abundance of natural antibodies in the plasma sample, as high titres are an indication that natural antibodies are at high concentrations even in increasingly diluted plasma . Similarly, higher titres for haemolysis indicate the plasma is able to lyse RRBCs even at more dilute concentrations . Thus, increased natural antibody levels and lysis ability are associated with increased immune function. We assessed bactericidal competence (BC) of plasma by quantifying its ability to inhibit growth of Escherichia coli using our published protocol for painted turtles [5, 97], adapted from . Five lyophilized pellets of E. coli (Microbiologics, ATCC#8739) were used in the present experiment, with each new pellet used to generate a new control solution as we progressed through samples. Increased bactericidal competence corresponds to increased immune function. All immune assays were conducted in spring of 2019 on samples collected in spring of 2018.
Immune measure: statistical analyses
Dependent variables were analyzed using general linear models with explanatory variables of: zAge (standardized age within each sex); Sex (adult males and adult females); the two-way interaction between zAge and Sex; and the nuisance variable assay batch (BC: N = 4; NAbs and Lysis: N = 2) to account for control pellets (BC) or bottle of rabbit red blood cells (NAbs and Lysis). Bactericidal Competence was Arcsine transformed to account for proportional data and to meet conditions of normality. NAbs and Lysis were log-10 transformed to meet conditions of normality. All linear models were performed in SAS v. 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA). Graphs were made in ggplot2 .
Availability of data and materials
The data from this study are available on DataShare: the Open Data Repository of Iowa State University (https://doi.org/10.25380/iastate.132220xxx).
Harman D. Aging: overview. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2001;928:1–21.
Ricklefs RE. The evolution of senescence from a comparative perspective. Funct Ecol. 2008;22:379–92.
Jones OR, Scheuerlein A, Salguero-Gómez R, Camarda CG, Schaible R, Casper BB, et al. Diversity of ageing across the tree of life. Nature. 2014;505(7482):169–73.
Schwanz L, Warner DA, McGaugh S, Di Terlizzi R, Bronikowski AM. State-dependent physiological maintenance in a long-lived ectotherm, the painted turtle (Chrysemys picta). J Exp Biol. 2011;214:88–97.
Judson JM, Reding DM, Bronikowski AM. Immunosenescence and its influence on reproduction in a long-lived vertebrate. J Exp Biol. 2020;223:jeb223057.
Peters A, Delhey K, Nakagawa S, Aulsebrook A, Verhulst S. Immunosenescence in wild animals: meta-analysis and outlook. Ecol Lett. 2019;22:1709–22.
Schmid-Hempel P. Variation in immune defence as a question of evolutionary ecology. Proc R Soc B. 2003;270(1513):357–66.
Hoekstra LA, Schwartz TS, Sparkman AM, Miller DA, Bronikowski AM. The untapped potential of reptile biodiversity for understanding how and why animals age. Funct Ecol. 2020;34:38–54.
Franceschi C, Capri M, Monti D, Giunta S, Olivieri F, Sevini F, et al. Inflammaging and anti-inflammaging: a systemic perspective on aging and longevity emerged from studies in humans. Mech Age Develop. 2007;128:92–105.
Pawelec G, Bronikowski AM, Cunnane SC, Ferrucci L, Franceschi C, Fülöp T, Gaudreau P, Gladyshev VN, Gonos ES, Gorbunova V, Kennedy BK, Larbi A, Lemaître JF, Liu GH, Maier AB, Morais JA, Nóbrega OT, Moskalev A, Rikkert MO, Seluanov A, Senior AM, Ukraintseva S, Vanhaelen Q, Witkowski J, Cohen AA. The conundrum of human immune system “senescence.” Mech Age Develop. 2020;192.
Schwartz TS, Bronikowski AM. Molecular stress pathways and the evolution of reproduction and aging in reptiles. In (T. Flatt & A. Heyland, eds.) Molecular mechanisms of life history evolution. Oxford: Oxford Univ Press; 2011. Pp. 193–209
Armstrong DP, Keevil MG, Rollinson NJ, Brooks RJ. Subtle individual variation in indeterminate growth leads to major variation in survival and lifetime reproductive output in a long-lived reptile. Funct Ecol. 2007;32:752–61.
Omeyer LCM, Fuller WJ, Godley BJ, Snape RTE, Broderick AC. Determinate or indeterminate growth? Revisiting the growth strategy of sea turtles. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 2018;596:199–211.
Bronikowski AM, Arnold SJ. The evolutionary ecology of life history variation in the garter snake Thamnophis elegans. Ecology. 1999;80:2314–25.
Congdon JD, Nagle RD, Kinney OM, van Loben Sels RC. Hypotheses of aging in a long-lived vertebrate, Blanding's turtle (Emydoidea blandingii). Exp Gerontol. 2001;36:813–27.
Wilkinson PM, Rainwater TR, Woodward AR, Leone EH, Carter C. Determinate growth and reproductive lifespan in the American Alligator (Alligator mississippiensis): evidence from long-term recaptures. Copeia. 2016;104:843–52.
Hoekstra LA, Weber RC, Bronikowski AM, Janzen FJ. Sex-specific growth, shape, and their impacts on life history of a long-lived vertebrate. Evol Ecol Res. 2018;19(6):639–57.
Reinke BA, Cayuela H, Janzen FJ, Lemaître J-F. Gaillard J-M, plus 110 others. Diverse aging rates in ectothermic tetrapods provide insights for the evolution of aging and longevity. Science. 2022;376:1459–66.
Berkel C, Cacan E. Analysis of longevity in Chordata identifies species with exceptional longevity among taxa and points to the evolution of longer lifespans. Biogerontol. 2021;22:329–43.
Stark G, Tamar K, Itescu Y, Feldman A, Meiri S. Cold and isolated ectotherms: drivers of reptilian longevity. Biol J Linn Soc. 2018;125:730–40.
da Silva R, Conde DA, Baudisch A, Colchero F. Slow and negligible senescence among Testudines challenges evolutionary theories of senescence. Science. 2022;376:1466–70.
Charlesworth B. Fisher, Medawar, Hamilton and the evolution of aging. Genetics. 2000;156:927–31.
Zimmerman LM, Vogel LA, Bowden RM. Understanding the vertebrate immune system: insights from the reptilian perspective. J Exp Biol. 2010;213:661–71.
Zimmerman LM. The reptilian perspective on vertebrate immunity: 10 years of progress. J Exp Biol. 2020;223(Pt 21):jeb214171.
Palacios MG, Gangloff EJ, Reding DM, Bronikowski AM. Genetic background and thermal environment differentially influence the ontogeny of immune components during early life in an ectothermic vertebrate. J Anim Ecol. 2020;89:1883–94.
Field EK, Hartzheim A, Terry J, Dawson G, Haydt N, Neuman-Lee LA. Reptilian innate immunology and Ecoimmunology: what do we know and where are we going? Integra Comp Biol. 2022;62:1557–71.
Palacios MG, Bronikowski AM. Immune variation during pregnancy suggests immune component-specific costs of reproduction in a viviparous snake with disparate life-history strategies. J Exp Zool Part A. 2017;327:513–22.
Bronikowski AM, Meisel RP, Biga PR, Walters JR, Mank JE, Larschan E, et al. Sex-specific aging in animals: perspective and future directions. Aging Cell. 2022;21:e13542.
Reed TE, Kruuk LE, Wanless S, Frederiksen M, Cunningham EJ, Harris MP. Reproductive senescence in a long-lived seabird: rates of decline in late-life performance are associated with varying costs of early reproduction. Am Nat. 2008;171:E89–E101.
Warner DA, Miller DA, Bronikowski AM, Janzen FJ. Decades of field data reveal that turtles senesce in the wild. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2016;113(23):6502–7.
Reinke BA, Miller DAW, Janzen FJ. What have long-term field studies taught us about population dynamics? Ann Rev Ecol Evol Sys. 2019;50(1):261–78.
Zimmerman LM, Bowden RM, Vogel LA. Red-eared slider turtles lack response to immunization with keyhole limpet hemocyanin but have high levels of natural antibodies. ISRN Zool. 2013a;2013:1–7.
Iverson JB. Climate-mediated recruitment failure in a turtle population and its bearing on northern limits of distribution. Chelonian Cons Biol. 2022;21(2):181–6.
Gibson CWD, Hamilton J. Population processes in a large herbivorous reptile: the Giant tortoise of Aldabra atoll. Oecologia. 1984;61:230–40.
Miller DAW, Janzen FJ, Fellers GM, Kleeman PM, Bronikowski AM. Biodemography of ectothermic tetrapods provides insights into the evolution and plasticity of mortality patterns. In: Weinstein M, Lane MA, editors. Sociality, hierarchy, health: comparative biodemography. Washington DC: National Academies Press; 2014. p. 295–313.
Reinke BA, Hoekstra L, Bronikowski AM, Janzen FJ, Miller DAW. Joint estimation of growth and survival from mark–recapture data to improve estimates of senescence in wild populations. Ecology. 2020;101(1):e02877. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.2877.
Keevil, M. G. 2020. Joint estimation of growth and survival from mark–recapture data to improve estimates of senescence in wild populations: comment. Ecology e03232. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.3232.
Bronikowski AM, Reinke BA, Hoekstra L, Janzen FJ, Miller DAW. Joint estimation of growth and survival from mark–recapture data to improve estimates of senescence in wild populations: reply. Ecology. 2022:103:e03571. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.3571.
Cayuela H, Akani GC, Hema EM, Eniang EE, Amadi N, Ajong SN, et al. Life history and age-dependent mortality processes in tropical reptiles. Biol J Linn Soc. 2019;128:251–62.
Gibbons JW. Why do turtles live so long? Bioscience. 1987;37:262–9.
Congdon JD, van Loben Sels RC. Relationships of reproductive traits and body size with attainment of sexual maturity and age in Blanding’s turtles (Emydoidea blandingii). J Evol Biol. 1993;6:547–57.
Miller JK. Escaping senescence: demographic data from the three-toed box turtle (Terrapene carolina triunguis). Exp Gerontol. 2001;36(4–6):829–32.
Moll EO. Reproductive cycles and adaptations. In: Harless M, Morlock H, editors. Turtles: perspectives and research. Malabar, Florida: John Wiley and Sons; 1979. p. 305–20.
Iverson JB, Lindeman PV, Lovich J. Understanding reproductive allometry in turtles: a slippery slope. Ecol Evol. 2019;9:11891–903.
Iverson JB. Chrysemys picta bellii (Western painted turtle). Longevity. Herpetol Rev. 2022;53:484.
Litzgus JD. Sex differences in longevity in the spotted turtle (Clemmys guttata). Copeia. 2006;2006:281–8.
Ernst CH. Growth of the spotted turtle (Clemmys guttata). J Herp. 1975;9:313–8.
Brown DJ, Schrage M, Ryan D, Moen RA, Nelson MD, Buech RR. Glyptemys insculpta (wood turtle) longevity in the wild. Herpetol Rev. 2015;46:243–4.
Iverson JB, Smith GR, Rettig JE. Body size, growth, and longevity in the northern map turtle (Graptemys geographica) in Indiana. J Herp. 2019;53:297–301.
Munscher E, Campbell K, Hauge JB, Hootman T, Osborne W, Butterfield BP, et al. Pseudemys floridana peninsularis (peninsular Cooter) and Pseudemys nelsoni (Florida red-bellied Cooter). Longevity. Herpetol Rev. 2020;51:111–3.
Lewis EL, Iverson JB. Terrapene ornata (ornate box turtle). Longevity. Herpetol Rev. 2018;49:530.
Lewis EL, Iverson JB, Smith GR, Rettig JE. Body size and growth in the red-eared slider (Trachemys scripta) at the northern edge of its range: does Bergmann’s rule apply? Herp Conserv Biol. 2018;13:700–10.
Curtin AJ, Zug GR, Spotila JR. Longevity and growth strategies of the desert tortoise (Gopherus agassizii) in two American deserts. J Arid Environ. 2009;73:463–71.
Medica PA, Nussear KE, Esque TC, Saethre MB. Long-term growth of desert tortoises (Gopherus agassizii) in a southern Nevada population. J Herpetol. 2012;46:213–20.
Klein SL. Hormones and mating system affect sex and species differences in immune function among vertebrates. Behav Proc. 2000;51:149–66.
Klein SL. Hormonal and immunological mechanisms mediating sex differences in parasite infection. Parasite Immunol. 2004;26:247–64.
Foo YZ, Nakagawa S, Rhodes G, Simmons LW. The effects of sex hormones on immune function: a meta-analysis. Biol Rev. 2007;92:551–71.
Kelly CD, Stoehr AM, Nunn C, Smyth KN, Prokop ZM. Sexual dimorphism in immunity across animals: a meta-analysis. Ecol Lett. 2018;21:1885–94.
Janzen FJ, Paukstis GL. Environmental sex determination in reptiles: ecology, evolution, and experimental design. Q Rev Biol. 1991;66(2):149–79.
López-Pérez JE, Meylan PA, Goessling JM. Sex-based trade-offs in the innate and acquired immune systems of Sternotherus minor. J Exp Zool. 2021;333:820–8.
Zimmerman LM, Paitz RT, Vogel LA, Bowden RM. Variation in the seasonal patterns of innate and adaptive immunity in the red-eared slider (Trachemys scripta). J Exp Biol. 2010;213:1477–148358.
Zimmerman LM, Clairardin SG, Paitz RT, Hicke JW, LaMagdeleine KA, Vogel LA, et al. Humoral immune responses are maintained with age in a long-lived ectotherm, the red-eared slider turtle. J Exp Biol. 2013b;216:633–40.
Freedberg S, Greives TJ, Ewert MA, Demas GE, Beecher N, Nelson CE. Incubation environment affects immune system development in a turtle with environmental sex determination. J Herpetol. 2008;2008(42):536–41.
Lee KA. Linking immune defenses and life history at the levels of the individual and the species. Integr Comp Biol. 2006;46:1000–15.
Sheldon BC, Verhulst S. Ecological immunology: costly parasite defences and trade-offs in evolutionary ecology. Trends Ecol Evol. 1996;11:317–21.
Palacios MG, Cunnick JE, Bronikowski AM. Complex interplay of condition, life-history, and prevailing environment shape immune defenses of snakes in the wild. Physiol Biochem Zool. 2013;86:547–58.
Iverson JB. Nesting and parental care in the turtle, Kinosternon flavescens. Can J Zool. 1990;68:230–233.
Licht P. Endocrine patterns in the reproductive cycle of turtles. Herpetologica. 1982;38:51–61.
Graham SP, Ward CK, Walker JS, Sterrett S, Mendonça MT. Sexual dimorphism and sexual variation of reproductive hormones in the Pascagoula Map Turtle, Graptemys gibbonsi. Copeia. 2015;103:42–50.
Shelby JA, Mendonça MT, Horne BD, Seigel RA. Seasonal variation in reproductive steroids of male and female yellow-blotched map turtles, Graptemys flavimaculata. Gen Comp Endocrinol. 2000;119:43–51.
Muñoz FJ, Galván A, Lerma M, De la Fuente M. Seasonal changes in peripheral blood leukocyte functions of the turtle Mauremys caspica and their relationship with corticosterone, 17-beta-estradiol and testosterone serum levels. Vet Immunol Immunopathol. 2000;77(1–2):27–42.
Blanvillain G, Owens DW, Kuchling G. Hormones and reproductive cycles in turtles. In: Norris DO, Lopez KH, editors. Hormones and reproduction of vertebrates, vol. 3. San Diego: Elsevier; 2011. p. 277–303.
Currylow AF, Tift MS, Meyer JL, Crocker DE, Williams RN. Seasonal variations in plasma vitellogenin and sex steroids in male and female eastern box turtles, Terrapene carolina. Gen Comp Endocrinol. 2013;80:48–55.
Freneau GE, Sá VA, Franci CR, Vieira D, Freneau BN. Gonadotrophic, prolactin, corticosterone, and gonadal hormones levels over 15 months in Giant Amazon river turtles –Podocnemis expansa (Schweigger, 1812) (Testudines: Podocnemididae), in captive conditions. Braz J Biol. 2017;77:347–55.
Mendonça MT, Licht P. Seasonal cycles in gonadal activity and plasma gonadotropin in the musk turtle, Sternotherus odoratus. Gen Comp Endocrinol. 1986;62:459–469.
Stearns SC. The evolution of life histories. UK: Oxford University Press; 1992.
Roff DA. Life history evolution. 2002. Sinauer, Sunderland, US; 2002.
Sheldon BC, Verhulst S. Ecological immunology: costly parasite defenses and trade-offs in evolutionary ecology. Trends Ecol Evol. 1996;11:317–21.
Lind CM, Agugliaro J, Farrell TM. The metabolic response to an immune challenge in a viviparous snake, Sistrurus miliarius. J Exp Biol. 2020;223:10:jeb225185.
Sparkman AM, Palacios MG. A test of life-history theories of immune defence in two ecotypes of the garter snake, Thamnophis elegans. J Anim Ecol. 2009;78:1242–1248.
Plasman M, Sandoval-Zapotitla E, Torres R. Immune response declines with age in a wild lizard. Biol J Linn Soc. 2019;128:936–43.
Ujvari B, Madsen T. Do natural antibodies compensate for humoral immunosenescence in tropical pythons. Funct Ecol. 2011;25(4):813–7.
Franceschi C, Bonafé M, Valensin S, Olivieri F, de Luca M, Ottaviani E, et al. Inflamm-aging: an evolutionary perspective on Immunosenescence. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2000;908:244–54.
Müller L, Fülöp T, Pawelec, G. Immunosenescence in vertebrates and invertebrates. Immun Ageing 2014;10:12. https://doi.org/10.1186/1742-4933-10-12.
Son NH, Joyce B, Hieatt A, Chrest FJ, Yanovski J, Weng NP. Stable telomere length and telomerase expression from naıve to memory B-lymphocyte differentiation. Mech Age Develop. 2003;124:427–32.
Vermeulen A, Eens M, Van Dongen S, Müller W. Does baseline innate immunity change with age? A multi-year study in great tits. Exp Geront. 2017;92:67–73.
Vogel LA, Palackdharry S, Zimmerman LM, Bowden RM. Humoral immune function in long-lived ectotherms, the reptiles. In: Fulop T, Franceschi C, Hirokawa K, Pawelec G, editors. Handbook of Immunosenescence. New York: Springer; 2018. p. 1–17.
Iverson JB. Life history and demography of the yellow mud turtle. Kinosternon flavescens Herpetologica. 1991;47:373–95.
Christiansen JL, Cooper JA, Bickham JW, Galloway BJ, Springer MA. Aspects of the natural history of the yellow mud turtle, Kinosternon flavescens (Kinosternidae) in Iowa: a proposed endangered species. Southwest Nat. 1985;30:413–525.
Colchero F, Jones OR, Rebke M. BaSTA: an R package for Bayesian estimation of age-specific survival from incomplete mark-recapture/recovery data with covariates. Methods Ecol Evol. 2012;3:466–70.
Ruby JG, Smith M, Buffenstein R. Naked mole-rat mortality rates defy Gompertzian laws by not increasing with age. eLIFE. 2018;7:e31157.
Iverson JB. Kinosternon flavescens (yellow mud turtle). Female growth and longevity. Herpetol Rev. 2017;48:178–179.
Christiansen JL, Dunham AE. Reproduction of the yellow mud turtle (Kinosternon flavescens flavescens) in New Mexico. Herpetologica. 1972;28:130–7.
Ochsenbein AF, Zinkernagel RM. Natural antibodies and complement link innate and acquired immunity. Immunol Today. 2000;21:624–30.
Sandmeier FC, Tracy CR, DuPré S, Hunter K. A trade-off between natural and acquired antibody production in a reptile: implications for long-term resistance to disease. Biology Open. 2012;1:1078–82.
Matson KD, Ricklefs RE, Klasing KC. A hemolysis-hemagglutination assay for characterizing constitutive innate humoral immunity in wild and domestic birds. Develop Comp Immunol. 2005;29:275–86.
Refsnider JM, Palacios MG, Reding DM, Bronikowski AM. Effects of a novel climate on stress response and immune function in painted turtles (Chrysemys picta). J Exp Zool A. 2015;323:160–8.
Matson,KD, Tieleman BI Klasing,KC. Capture stress and the bactericidal competence of blood and plasma in five species of tropical birds. Physiol Biochem Zool. 2006;79:556–564. https://doi.org/10.1086/501057.
Wickham H. ggplot2: elegant graphics for data analysis. New York: Springer-Verlag; 2016.
Permissions to undertake the field work were provided by the Crescent Lake National Wildlife Refuge, the Nebraska Games and Parks Commission. We also thank the many former Earlham students who provided field assistance over the past four decades.
Funding for this research was provided by Earlham College, the Joseph Moore Museum of Natural History, the National Science Foundation (IOS–1257857 to F.J. Janzen and D.A. Warner through Iowa State University), and the National Institute on Aging (R01AI154458).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Annual permits for the field work were provided by the Nebraska Game and Parks Commission. Most of the field work was done before the advent of the Earlham College Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee but was approved by that committee beginning in 2014 (20140516-2JI). This work was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at Iowa State University (#3-2-5125-J). For the entire project, we abided by the ethical guidelines published by the SSAR Guidelines for the Use of Live Amphibians and Reptiles in Field Research.
Consent for publication
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Bronikowski, A.M., Hedrick, A.R., Kutz, G.A. et al. Sex-specific innate immunity and ageing in long-lived fresh water turtles (Kinosternon flavescens: Kinosternidae). Immun Ageing 20, 11 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12979-023-00335-x